Skip to content

Review History

Reviews

Date Branch Gate Critical High Medium Low Agents
2026-02-19 feature/spec-002-security-review-enforcement PASS 0 0 2 3 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-02-19 feature/spec-002-security-review-enforcement PASS 0 0 2 2 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-02-19 feature/spec-004-scaffold-template-patterns PASS 0 0 2 3 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-02-20 feature/spec-008-knowledge-inbox-pipeline PASS 0 0 4 2 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-02-21 feature/vt-c-content-evaluate-skill PASS 0 0 3 3 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-02-21 feature/spec-006-workflow-sequence-enforcement PASS 0 0 3 5 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-02-21 feature/spec-010-web-capture PASS 0 0 3 2 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-02-22 feature/spec-014-unified-init PASS 0 0 4 3 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-02-25 feature/spec-021-ims-plugin-extraction PASS 0 0 1 2 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-02-25 feature/spec-022-session-start-notifications PASS 0 0 3 5 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-02-26 feature/spec-023-deploy-gate-integration PASS 0 0 4 9 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-02-26 feature/spec-024-review-autofix-loop PASS 0 0 2 4 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-02-28 feature/spec-025-mcp-configuration-patterns PASS 0 0 1 2 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-02-28 main (11 merged branches post-SPEC-025) PASS 0 1 3 4 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-02-28 fix/cli-import-pipeline-data-root PASS 0 0 4 3 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-02-28 fix/cli-import-pipeline-data-root (re-review) PASS 0 0 4 5 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-01 feature/spec-032-agent-worktree-isolation PASS 0 0 2 4 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-01 feature/spec-032-agent-worktree-isolation (re-review) PASS 0 0 1 2 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-02 feature/spec-030-intelligent-skill-activation PASS 0 0 3 2 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-02 feature/spec-029-skill-permission-governance PASS 0 1 2 5 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-02 feature/spec-029-skill-permission-governance (re-review) PASS 0 1 3 5 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-02 feature/spec-029-skill-permission-governance (re-review 2) PASS 0 1 3 8 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-03 feature/spec-039-ufi-country-enrichment PASS 0 0 1 0 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-04 feature/spec-46-config-drift-audit PASS 0 0 1 3 security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-08 feature/spec-028-security-review-pipeline PASS 0 0 2 5 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-09 feature/spec-054-wave-dependency-execution PASS 0 0 2 3 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-09 feature/spec-049-workflow-merger PASS 0 0 0 2 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-09 feature/spec-033-claudemd-lifecycle PASS 0 0 2 3 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-09 feature/spec-051-spec-from-requirements PASS 0 0 1 2 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-09 feature/spec-045-commit-documentation-traceability PASS 0 0 1 1 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-09 feature/spec-041-adversarial-review-framing PASS 0 0 1 1 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-17 feature/spec-058-mcp-config-governance PASS 0 0 1 5 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-17 feature/knowledge-index PASS 0 0 5 3 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-17 feature/knowledge-index (re-review) PASS 0 0 5 5 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-17 feature/v000-projektupdates PASS 0 1 3 2 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, pattern-recognition-specialist, document-quality-reviewer
2026-03-17 feature/spec-072-cross-file-impact-analysis PASS 0 0 2 1 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-18 feature/spec-078-state-documentation-standard PASS 0 0 4 1 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-18 feature/spec-075-strategic-mentor-agent PASS 0 0 2 1 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-18 feature/spec-079-repo-evaluation-safety PASS 0 0 3 2 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-18 feature/spec-081-simplify-skill-enhancement PASS 0 0 2 2 document-quality-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-18 feature/spec-081-simplify-skill-enhancement (pass 2) PASS 0 0 2 4 spec-compliance-reviewer, document-quality-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist, accessibility-reviewer
2026-03-19 feature/spec-076-ims-audit-extensions PASS 0 0 3 4 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-19 feature/spec-077-advanced-diagram-generation PASS 0 0 2 3 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist, accessibility-reviewer
2026-03-19 claude/review-next-spec-BvgfC (SPEC-054 re-review) PASS 0 0 3 2 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-19 claude/review-next-spec-BvgfC (SPEC-075) PASS 0 0 1 2 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-19 claude/review-next-spec-BvgfC (SPEC-076) PASS 0 0 0 0 29 tests pass, 0 regressions
2026-03-19 claude/review-next-spec-BvgfC (SPEC-078) PASS 0 0 0 0 Plan validated in 2 iterations, all 6 FRs covered
2026-03-23 feature/spec-93-worktree-activate-integration PASS 0 0 0 2 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-23 feature/spec-86-brownfield-repo-onboarding PASS 0 0 3 7 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-23 feature/spec-88-secret-detection-hooks PASS 0 1 1 8 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-23 feature/spec-83-adr-workflow PASS 0 0 1 3 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-23 feature/spec-84-garbage-collection-agent PASS 0 0 2 2 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-23 feature/spec-87-diagram-auto-validation PASS 0 0 2 3 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-24 feature/spec-090-user-manual-generation PASS 0 0 2 4 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist, accessibility-reviewer
2026-03-24 feature/spec-091-user-manual-update PASS 0 0 3 5 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-24 feature/spec-095-workflow-gate-enforcement PASS 0 0 2 3 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-24 feature/spec-096-ims-cross-file-gaps PASS 0 0 2 4 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist, document-quality-reviewer
2026-03-28 feature/spec-097-ims-to-vms-rename FAIL 1 5 1 0 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, pattern-recognition-specialist, code-simplicity-reviewer
2026-03-28 feature/spec-097-ims-to-vms-rename (pass 2) PASS 0 2 2 0 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, pattern-recognition-specialist, code-simplicity-reviewer
2026-03-27 feature/spec-097-ims-to-vms-rename (pass 3) PASS 0 2 4 1 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-28 feature/spec-097-ims-to-vms-rename (pass 4) PASS 0 1 2 1 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-27 feature/spec-097-ims-to-vms-rename (pass 5) PASS 0 0 1 3 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-29 feature/spec-098-skill-testing-framework PASS 0 2 5 3 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-30 feature/spec-100-designmd-pattern-evaluation PASS 0 0 4 1 spec-compliance-reviewer, research-quality-reviewer
2026-03-27 feature/spec-101-design-system-infrastructure PASS 0 3 3 2 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-27 feature/spec-101-design-system-infrastructure (pass 2) FAIL 1 1 3 4 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-27 feature/spec-101-design-system-infrastructure (pass 3) PASS 0 0 3 4 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-30 feature/spec-102-memory-consolidation PASS 0 0 2 2 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-30 feature/spec-099-remotion-video-skill PASS 0 0 3 3 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-30 feature/spec-103-security-hardening PASS 0 0 4 6 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist, document-quality-reviewer
2026-03-31 feature/spec-104-memory-consolidation-dream PASS 0 0 2 3 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-30 feature/spec-105-recursive-criticism-improvement PASS 0 0 3 2 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-31 feature/spec-106-autoresearch-optimization-agent PASS 0 0 0 4 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-03-31 feature/spec-107-dream-open-brain PASS 0 0 2 4 spec-compliance-reviewer, security-sentinel, kieran-typescript-reviewer, julik-frontend-races-reviewer, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-04-20 feature/spec-114-security-baseline-hardening PASS 0 1 3 9 security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist
2026-04-20 feature/spec-114-security-baseline-hardening (pass 2) PASS 0 0 0 6 security-sentinel, code-simplicity-reviewer, performance-oracle, pattern-recognition-specialist

Recurring Findings

Finding Type Frequency First Seen Agent Action Taken
Unrelated changes bundled in feature branch 17 2026-02-19 code-simplicity-reviewer, pattern-recognition-specialist, security-sentinel Recurring 17x — promoted to critical-patterns.md at 3x. Still occurring. Consider tooling enforcement.
argument-hint in new SKILL.md despite documentation saying not to 9 2026-02-20 pattern-recognition-specialist, code-simplicity-reviewer 9x — SPEC-104 dream skill also includes argument-hint. Pre-existing from SPEC-102 creation. Documented as "harmlessly ignored" in core-standards-rules.md.
plugin.json description inconsistent with constitution 2 2026-02-21 code-simplicity-reviewer 2x — "two-workflow architecture" vs "Two-Workflow Model" in constitution. Pre-existing, fixed in doc-sync.
Stale test gate from different branch 15 2026-02-25 code-simplicity-reviewer 15x -- SPEC-114 started review with .test-gate.md and .review-gate.md from feature/spec-110 (2026-04-04). Test gate is per-branch but not auto-refreshed on branch switch. Consider auto-invalidation on branch switch via branch-switch-gate-invalidation.sh hook (already registered but may not fire on worktree switch).
Hardcoded Airtable infrastructure IDs 3 2026-02-28 security-sentinel, pattern-recognition-specialist 3x -- main review flagged table IDs and hierarchy record IDs; first fix review flagged hierarchy IDs moved to config without env-var override; re-review confirms same. Promote to critical-patterns.md when file is created.
Incomplete bulk rename (directory renamed but body references not updated) 1 2026-03-28 spec-compliance-reviewer, pattern-recognition-specialist 1x -- SPEC-097 renamed directories and frontmatter but left 72+ body references unchanged. Auto-fixed in Pass 2.
Hardcoded user path in committed settings 1 2026-03-28 security-sentinel 1x -- .claude/settings.json committed with /Users/rolf/ path. Related to P-002.

Agent Effectiveness

Agent Reviews Run Findings Critical Catches
security-sentinel 65 67 0
kieran-typescript-reviewer 42 6 0
julik-frontend-races-reviewer 42 10 0
code-simplicity-reviewer 68 144 0
performance-oracle 58 29 0
pattern-recognition-specialist 67 153 1
spec-compliance-reviewer 41 34 0
document-quality-reviewer 5 13 0
accessibility-reviewer 3 1 0
research-quality-reviewer 1 5 0